We were in New York City last weekend. Man, that city is expensive, busy, and makes me feel happy we live in Boston. Getting there is not easy, especially if you’re considering traveling green and making smart fiscal decisions.
The cost debate:
- Amtrak: $450 round trip for two people. Acela on the way to NYC, Northeast Regional back to Boston.
- Flying: Prices vary by day/time/weekend, but generally it’s not much cheaper than Amtrak. To fly on a weekend mid-April it’s $336 per person on JetBlue. Plus the cost to get into the city.
- Bus: Amenities are nice (bathroom, wifi, etc), and cost is relatively cheap (approx $80 for two people round trip). Time is the issue. Last time we took the bus on a Friday night it took nearly 6 hours!
- Driving: If you’ve already got the car, it’s simply the cost of a tank of gas and tolls (about $75 total).
Generally speaking, the rail systems are going to be your most eco-friendly transportation. They’re transporting a large number of people at once, and operate on a fairly energy efficient system.
A similar debate can be made for flying – transporting a large number of people, fairly efficient. Short haul flights (Boston to NYC) are mostly on par with rail for emissions and efficiency.
Driving is probably the next best alternative, especially if you can carpool or drive a hybrid. Kudos if you can do both!
Finally, the bus. We really don’t like the bus. Depending on your time of travel, the bus can be either one of the most efficient or least efficient methods of transport. Couple that with the bus being loud and the longest of the travel methods, and we think you’re best to just avoid it.
In conclusion, if you’re a big spender, go with Amtrak. You’ll love it. If you’re like the remaining 99.99% of the population, we suggest driving from Boston to NYC.